American Fidelity Assurance Company
Oklahoma City, OK
American Fidelity Assurance Company of Oklahoma City, OK is the broker of record on 111 Form 5500 Schedule A filings covering 73 employer benefit plans across 21 states, with $2,781,068 in reported broker commissions (plan year 2025).
Quick answer
American Fidelity Assurance Company (Oklahoma City, OK) is the broker of record for 73 employer benefit plan sponsors on 111 Form 5500 Schedule A filings, plan year 2025.
- How many employer clients does American Fidelity Assurance Company have?
- American Fidelity Assurance Company is named as broker on Form 5500 Schedule A filings for 73 distinct plan sponsors in 21 states.
- Who are American Fidelity Assurance Company's largest employer clients?
- By plan participants, the largest include Pennsylvania Automotive Association (18,529 participants), Pennsylvania Automotive Association (5,447 participants) and J C Lewis Motor Co., Inc. (1,300 participants).
- How much does American Fidelity Assurance Company earn in commissions?
- Insurers reported $2.8 million in broker commissions paid to American Fidelity Assurance Company for plan year 2025, per Schedule A Part 1.
- Where is American Fidelity Assurance Company located?
- American Fidelity Assurance Company is based in Oklahoma City, OK and has employer clients in 21 states.
- How does American Fidelity Assurance Company rank among benefits brokers in Oklahoma?
- American Fidelity Assurance Company ranks #3 by employer clients among the 50 most active benefits brokers based in Oklahoma.
Source: Fundz verified event record.
Employer clients
Plan sponsors naming American Fidelity Assurance Company on a Form 5500 Schedule A, largest first. Sponsor name, state, participant count and plan year end come directly from the filing.
| Employer | State | Participants | Plan year end |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pennsylvania Automotive Association | PA | 18,529 | 2025-12-31 |
| Pennsylvania Automotive Association | PA | 5,447 | 2025-12-31 |
| J C Lewis Motor Co., Inc. | GA | 1,300 | 2025-06-30 |
Sell through benefits brokers? Let us show you around.
Reach the brokers who place employer plans in their state, and the employers growing there. In 20 minutes we will walk you through the broker directory and the employer signals behind it, using your market.
Book a 20-minute walkthroughKnow who holds the account, and when it renews.
Every US employer benefit plan with its broker of record, reported commissions, participant count and renewal month, read from the most recent Form 5500 Schedule A and joined to funding rounds, executive hires and layoff notices.
Other benefits brokers in Oklahoma
- Relation Insurance Services, Inc.: 110 employer clients, $10,352,849 reported commissions (Tulsa)
- Paycom Payroll LLC: 86 employer clients, $10,576 reported commissions (Oklahoma City)
- Hub International Mid-America: 62 employer clients, $3,058,473 reported commissions (Tulsa)
- Nfp Corporate Services (Ok), LLC: 29 employer clients, $2,463,676 reported commissions (Oklahoma City)
- Inservices, LLC: 27 employer clients, $3,179,693 reported commissions (Enid)
- Bancfirst Insurance Services, Inc.: 25 employer clients, $1,926,845 reported commissions (Tulsa)
- Insurica, Inc.: 24 employer clients, $1,246,515 reported commissions (Oklahoma City)
- Kelly W Pugh: 18 employer clients, $28,550 reported commissions (Broken Arrow)
Form 5500 Schedule A Part 1 (broker of record), 2024 to 2025 plan years. Source: U.S. Department of Labor EFAST2. Commission and fee figures are as reported by the plan's insurer on Schedule A Part 1 and are not adjusted.